Butterfinger Cupcakes

9

Share It if your Like it

Butterfinger Cupcakes are my go to move when I need something fun and sweet for a party, a school bake sale, or one of those long weeks when you just want a little pick me up. You know the feeling when you volunteer to bring dessert and suddenly you have zero time and zero inspiration? Yep, that moment. These cupcakes solve it because they taste like you went all out, but they are actually pretty simple. They are chocolatey, a little salty, and packed with that crunchy candy bar vibe that makes people go back for a second one. If you like peanut butter and chocolate together, you are basically already sold.

The Story Behind This Recipe

Hey, I’m Alexandraa! This Butterfinger Cupcakes was built for real kitchens: simple steps, reliable results, and flavor that makes people ask for seconds. Butterfinger Cupcakes are my go to move when I need something fun and sweet for a party, a school bake sale, or one of those long…

Alexandraa

Butterfinger Cupcakes: A Holiday Dessert Pick Me Up!

I started making these around the holidays because cookie trays were starting to feel like a full time job. I wanted something that looked festive and felt special, but did not require a million steps. Butterfinger Cupcakes hit that sweet spot: they are cozy enough for winter gatherings, but honestly they work all year.

The best part is the reaction. People spot the crushed candy on top and immediately ask what they are. Then they take a bite and you get that little pause, the one that says, ok wow, this is good. The cupcake is soft, the frosting is creamy, and the candy pieces add crunch without making the whole thing hard to eat.

Why they feel extra perfect for celebrations

It is not just the flavor, it is the whole vibe. You get the nostalgic candy bar thing plus the bakery style frosting swirl. If you are doing a dessert table, these hold their own next to fancy treats. Also, they travel well if you store them right, so you can bring them to work parties or family dinners without stress.

Little personal note: I made a batch for a holiday movie night once, and my friend who always says she only wants something small ate two and asked if she could take one home. That is the energy we want from dessert.

“I made these for our office party and they were the first dessert to disappear. Even people who said they were not into cupcakes came back for another.”

If you are in a big Butterfinger mood and want another easy treat for gifting, I also really like these Butterfinger balls. They are great for snack boxes and they disappear fast.

An Easy Butterfinger Dessert Idea

Let us talk about how to actually make them without making it a whole production. I am not here to make you dirty every bowl you own. This is a simple approach that still tastes like a bakery cupcake.

You can use a chocolate cupcake base from scratch or a boxed mix if that is what your schedule allows. I have done both. If you do boxed mix, just focus your energy on the frosting and the toppings, because that is where the Butterfinger magic really shows up.

What you will need

• Chocolate cupcakes baked and cooled (from scratch or a good quality box mix)
• Butterfinger bars crushed (save some bigger bits for topping)
• Butter softened
• Cream cheese softened (optional but I love it for a tangy balance)
• Powdered sugar
• Peanut butter creamy
• Vanilla extract
• A pinch of salt
• Milk or cream, just a splash if the frosting needs loosening

Simple directions (my no stress method)

1) Bake the chocolate cupcakes and cool them completely. If they are even a little warm, your frosting will slide around and you will be annoyed.

2) Crush the Butterfinger bars. I do a mix of fine crumbs and chunky pieces. A zip bag and a rolling pin works great, and it keeps cleanup easy.

3) Make the frosting: beat butter (and cream cheese if using) until smooth, then beat in peanut butter, vanilla, salt, and powdered sugar a bit at a time. Add a tiny splash of milk if it feels too thick.

4) Mix some Butterfinger crumbs into the frosting, not all of them. You want candy in every bite, but you also want the frosting to pipe nicely.

5) Frost the cupcakes and sprinkle the remaining crushed candy on top. Press a few bigger pieces into the frosting so it looks extra tempting.

Quick tip that saves the day: if your crushed candy is super sticky, pop it in the fridge for 10 minutes before topping. It behaves better and looks cleaner.

Also, if you love poke cake style desserts, this one is a fun cousin recipe to try later: Butterfinger poke cake. It is messy in a good way.

;

One more thing I learned the hard way: do not top these too far ahead if your kitchen is humid. The candy stays crunchy longer when you add it closer to serving time. You can still prep everything earlier, just sprinkle right before you set them out.

More Peanut Butter Desserts

If Butterfinger Cupcakes are your kind of dessert, you are probably also someone who loves peanut butter anything. Same here. Peanut butter is salty, creamy, and it makes chocolate taste even more chocolatey. It is like the flavor booster you did not know you needed.

When I am planning a dessert spread, I like to offer at least one peanut butter option because it always gets attention. And it is an easy way to balance super sweet treats with something that has a little salty edge.

If you want another peanut butter cupcake that is basically a guaranteed crowd pleaser, check out these Reeses peanut butter cupcakes. They have that candy shop feel but still feel homemade.

Or if you want something sliceable for a potluck, this Butterfinger bundt cake is a great option. Bundt cakes are low effort in the best way, and you can serve a lot of people without fiddling with frosting each piece.

My practical advice if you are baking with peanut butter often: keep a jar specifically for baking. It keeps you from realizing halfway through a recipe that someone used the last spoonful for toast.

LIKE THIS? THEN YOU’LL ALSO LOVE THESE! {video_youtube}

If you are in the mood to keep the candy themed dessert train going, I have a few favorites that hit similar notes. Some are crunchy, some are fudgy, some are straight up snackable. If you like Butterfinger Cupcakes, it is pretty likely you will like these too.

Here are a few ideas for your next baking day:

• Fudge lovers: try a candy crunch situation like Butterfinger caramel crunch fudge.
• Snack mix mood: if you want something you can eat by the handful, Butterfinger puppy chow is dangerously good.
• Cupcake variety: if you are building a cupcake table, something fruity like orange crush cupcakes is a fun contrast to all the chocolate.

Also, if you are serving kids, I like doing mini cupcakes and letting them add their own toppings. Set out bowls of crushed candy, chocolate chips, and sprinkles. It is a little messy, but it makes everyone happy.

Reader Interactions

I love hearing how these turn out in your kitchen because everyone has their own little twists. Some people add extra candy inside the cupcake, some drizzle chocolate on top, and some go heavy on the peanut butter. All valid choices.

If you make Butterfinger Cupcakes, tell me what you did with the frosting. Did you go classic peanut butter buttercream, or did you try the cream cheese version? And did you keep them full size or make minis?

Common Questions

1) Can I make them ahead of time?
Yes. Bake the cupcakes a day ahead and store them covered. Frost them the next day for the freshest look. If you need to frost ahead, wait to add the crushed candy until close to serving.

2) How do I keep the Butterfinger topping crunchy?
Add it right before serving if possible. If you must add it earlier, store the cupcakes in a cool, dry place and avoid sealing them in an overly humid container.

3) Can I fill the cupcakes?
Definitely. You can scoop a small hole in the center and add a spoon of chocolate ganache or a little peanut butter. Then frost as usual. It makes them feel extra bakery style.

4) What if my frosting is too thick or too runny?
Too thick: add milk or cream a teaspoon at a time. Too runny: add a bit more powdered sugar and chill the bowl for 10 minutes.

5) Can I make them without peanut butter?
You can do a vanilla buttercream and still use crushed Butterfinger on top, but the peanut butter flavor is part of what makes them taste like the candy bar. If you have an allergy, skip the peanut butter and choose a safe topping instead.

A sweet little baking win you can count on

If you want a dessert that feels festive without taking over your whole day, Butterfinger Cupcakes are the answer. They are simple, dependable, and they make people genuinely excited about dessert. If you want extra inspiration and cute decorating ideas, I have bookmarked Butterfinger Cupcakes | The Cake Blog and I also like the clear step by step vibe from Butterfinger Cupcakes – Sarahs Bake Studio. Now go crush some candy bars, whip up that frosting, and treat yourself to a batch you will be proud to share.