1.4K

Share It if your Like it

old fashioned sour cream donuts are the thing I make when I’m tired of paying bakery prices for something that’s… fine. You know? Like, good, but not “I just spent $18” good. The homemade version comes out craggy, tender, and kinda dramatic in the best way. If you want a glazed version too, I’ve got you covered with these old-fashioned sour cream glazed donuts (dangerously easy to snack on). And if you’re already in a cozy, sour-cream-ish mood, this Amish sour cream cornbread is the “why is this so good” side quest.

Old Fashioned Sour Cream Donuts Better Than the Bakery

What Are Old Fashioned Donuts?

Old fashioned donuts are the ones with the rough, cracked edges and that classic cake-donut bite. They’re not fluffy like yeast donuts. They’re more like… a donut that means business.

• They’re cake-style donuts, so they hold their shape and feel a bit sturdy (in a good way).
• The surface gets those crispy “petals” when fried right, which is honestly the whole point.
• Flavor is usually simple: vanilla, a little nutmeg, buttery vibes.

Why Sour Cream Makes Better Donuts

Sour cream is the not-so-secret secret. It makes the crumb soft without turning the donut into a sad, dry hockey puck.

• It adds fat + acidity, which helps keep the inside tender.
• The tang makes the flavor pop, even with a plain glaze.
• It helps you get that bakery-style texture… except fresher, and you didn’t have to stand in line behind someone ordering six complicated coffees.

Ingredients for Sour Cream Donuts

Nothing weird here. If you bake even a little, you probably have most of this already.

You’ll need:

• All-purpose flour (spoon it into the cup; don’t pack it down like you’re building a sandcastle)
• Sugar (granulated), plus powdered sugar if you’re glazing
• Baking powder + a pinch of baking soda (little lift, nice texture)
• Salt (don’t skip it—flat donuts are a bummer)
• Nutmeg (optional, but I vote yes)
• Butter (softened)
• Egg yolks (yolks make it rich—this is not the time to be “light”)
• Sour cream (full-fat is best)
• Vanilla extract

How to Make Old Fashioned Donuts Step by Step

This is straightforward, but the dough is a little sticky. That’s normal. Don’t panic and dump in a snowstorm of flour, okay?

1. Mix dry stuff. Flour, baking powder, baking soda, salt, nutmeg. Whisk it around.
2. Cream butter + sugar. Just until it looks kind of fluffy. Not a 10-minute workout.
3. Add yolks, then sour cream + vanilla. It’ll look messy for a second. Keep going.
4. Stir in dry mix. Stop when it comes together. Overmixing makes tough donuts (rude).
5. Chill the dough. At least 45–60 minutes. It firms up and becomes way less annoying.
6. Roll and cut. Light flour on the counter. About 1/2-inch thick. Cut donut shapes.
7. Fry. 325–350°F oil. Fry a couple at a time so the oil temp doesn’t crash.
   • About 1–2 minutes per side, depending on size.
   • You want deep golden, not “tan.”
8. Drain and cool. On a rack if you can. Paper towels work, but they can get soggy.

“I made these for Sunday brunch and my kids said they taste like the fancy donut shop downtown. My husband ate three before I even glazed them.”

Small tip from my own mistakes: your first donut is often the “tester donut.” Mine always looks a bit wonky. Still eaten immediately though, obviously.

The Perfect Glaze for Old Fashioned Donuts

Glaze should be thin enough to dip, thick enough to cling. If it runs off like water, nope.

Simple glaze I swear by:

• 2 cups powdered sugar
• 2–4 tbsp milk (add slowly)
• 1 tsp vanilla
• Pinch of salt (yes, even here)

Dip donuts when they’re slightly warm, not piping hot. Too hot and the glaze disappears. Too cold and it sits on top like frosting from a tub.

If you want a fun twist sometime, these cranberry orange sour cream scones have that same tangy-rich vibe, just in scone form (breakfast’s cousin).

Baked vs Fried Donut Options

Let’s be honest: frying tastes best. But baked has its place (like when you don’t want oil smell hanging around for two days).

Fried (best texture):

• Crispy edges, tender inside, classic “old fashioned” crags.
• Needs a thermometer. Guessing oil temp is how sadness happens.

Baked (still good, different):

• More muffin-like, less crisp.
• Use a donut pan if you have one, or a muffin tin in a pinch (it’s not the same, but it’s something).
• Bake around 350°F for 10–14 minutes, depending on size.

If you bake them, consider brushing with melted butter before glazing. It helps fake that fried richness. {image_7}

Storage and Make-Ahead Tips

Homemade donuts are best the same day. That’s not me being dramatic; it’s just true.

• Same-day: Keep loosely covered at room temp. Airtight can make the outside soft.
• Next day: Still edible, but the magic fades a bit. A 10-second microwave revive helps.
• Make-ahead dough: You can chill the dough overnight. Just cover it well so it doesn’t dry out.
• Glaze timing: Glaze right before serving if you want them pretty and crackly.

FAQ

What makes old fashioned donuts different?

They’re cake donuts with that cracked, crisp edge and a tighter crumb. Yeast donuts are fluffier and more bready.

Can I bake instead of fry?

Yep. Texture changes (more cakey), but it works. A donut pan helps a lot.

Why are my donuts dense?

Usually one of these:

• Too much flour (easy to do)
• Overmixing the dough
• Oil temp too low (they soak up oil and get heavy)

How long do homemade donuts last?

Best within 24 hours. After that, they’re not terrible, just… not peak donut.

Can I freeze donuts?

Yes. Freeze unglazed donuts wrapped tight. Thaw at room temp, warm briefly, then glaze.

Also, totally unrelated but also very related: if you ever need a savory sour cream moment, these loaded potato skins with sour cream are loud, crunchy, and unfairly good. {image_9}

Alright, go make the donut magic happen

If you want bakery-style old fashioned sour cream donuts without leaving your house (or putting on real pants), this recipe is it. Keep the dough chilled, don’t overmix, and fry at a steady temp—those three things fix like 90% of donut problems. For extra nerdy reassurance, I like comparing notes with Old-Fashioned Sour Cream Doughnuts – Handle the Heat when I’m tweaking tiny details. Now please go make a batch and tell me if you ate the first one standing at the counter… because that’s basically tradition.